FleaInNYCbanner.jpg

? Jitterbug Party | Main | Dwight Yoakam: Suspicious Minds ?

November 03, 2006

Strange new worlds

When I first heard Paramount was tinkering with original Trek with the aim to produce an "enhanced" version I can only describe my reaction as incredulous skepticism shading into trembling outrage. Visions of a Greedoesque farce with yet another George Lucas-style banalization of a cherished classic left me dreading the result. It was, therefore, with some trepidation that I started to watch the enhanced version of "Balance of Terror", my favourite ever Star Trek episode.

It is a tour de force. Paramount has left the original cheese-factor intact. If anything, these new versions max-out the cheese-factor rendering the enhanced Trek more original than the original. So what has been "enhanced", exactly? First, this post post-production punches up the blacks. Deep space now looks properly deep and every interior shot has the satisfying contrast of a multi-million dollar per episode contemporary effort such as the revamped Battlestar Galactica. Every time Uhura swivels on her communications station chair the rich luster of its pleatherette surface glints in the light of the bridge. The re-engineered sound of the enhanced Trek is also Immediately noticeable. Corridors and inter-ship announcements have been re-mastered with a subtle reverb, photon torpedoes detonate with a juicy thump and incidental music sounds richer; all of this without substituting new sound effects for old or replacing period music with some ludicrous contemporary version. Visual effects have been seriously juiced up. Planetscapes and exterior shots of various ships, most importantly Enterprise herself, are careful CGI reproductions of the original models. These new versions, however, are more detailed and have richer contrast. We can now see the turning of Enterprise' warp nacelles and phaser blasts light up the underside of her saucer section. The result is frankly wondrous. This is how the show was always supposed to look.

Where the enhanced version takes liberties with the original it does so in ways that are respectful and true to the aim of making the show more Trek than Trek. The original circular dots that stood in for passing stars in deep space are still circular dots passing for stars in deep space. But now each lovingly reproduced "star" produces depth of field with a subtle parallax motion in relation to its peers. My favourite addition so far is nictitating membrane action in "Arena"; Gorns can blink!

Flea-readers who have yet to see the enhanced Trek can check out side-by-side comparisons of original verses enhanced visual imagery at StarTrek.com. The enhanced title sequence demonstrates a number of the points I have outlined.

Humana humana Update: Just watched the enhanced "City On the Edge of Forever" featuring the enhanced Joan Collins, so hot she is from an alternate reality.

Posted by Ghost of a flea at November 3, 2006 08:47 AM

Comments

Kyool! Balance of Terror is my favourite episode, as well. I like the new Catspaw castle.

The ship entering orbit in the new opening sequence is nice; I would imagine they did a lot of work on that subject in many episodes - entering orbit, leaving orbit, ... there were a few scenes with the ship coming toward the camera/moving up while in orbit but it appears to be moving in a straight line upwards. I'd be interested to see how they might have treated those scenes. As well, those scenes where there were blue phaser blasts that lit up the whole scene; I'm sure all that's attended to.

But, have they enhanced the Orion slavegirl? (I'm talking about her skin colour!)

Posted by: The_Campblog [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 09:57 AM

Despite my growing skepticism of all things Trek, I will say that those updates are gorgeous and very much in the spirit of the show.

Whereas the Lucasian habit is to take an old classic, jam some thematically inappropriate new stuff on top, and claim it is just as good -- or better -- than the old one. Not unlike hastily slapping a jarring Postmodern monstrosity on top of a classic Romanesque Revival building.

Posted by: Chris Taylor [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 12:29 PM

Mike: Updated Orion slavegirl... hmmm...

Chris: I think the Royal Ontario Museum is very interesting and I had not thought of Lucas or Libeskind in the same frame before. That said, I am actually quite pleased with that exploding crystal. It opens the Museum up to a stretch of Bloor that has been a bit Death Star trench for decades and I think it does so without compromising the original facade and sight-lines along University/Avenue Rd., particularly now the condo tower has been nixed.

Posted by: Ghost of a flea [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 12:37 PM

Oh my oh my oh my...

My part is all a quiver with delight at this.

And don't you DARE tell me that my nom de plume was lifted from "The Squire of Gothos" or I'll verball abuse you over at Alans place.

My wife's fav ep is Devil in thedark so she will be pleased.

Posted by: Gorthos [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 01:31 PM

I'll give you hte red dwarfs - and the purple ones, too - but toggle switches are so 2260. What I don't understand is how a focused ray of pure energy in empty space is supposed to give off an illuminating glow that can light up the ship. Where do the deflections of photons come from?

And I just want to confirm that I don't know my place.

Posted by: Alan McLeod [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 03:00 PM

Were these lasers, Alan, you would be quite correct. Without a light-scattering medium (an atmosphere, dust, etc.) or ambient gas to be heated into a light-emitting plasma, laser-weapons would be invisible in space. Enterprise, however, is armed with phaser weapons which emit nadion-beams, nadions being sub-atomic particles which are, amongst their other qualities, light-emitting.

Please refer to Memory Alpha for details.

"Phaser" is an acronym for PHASed Energy Rectification. All phasers release an energy beam. Personal phasers can stun or kill an enemy. The stun setting can also be used for crowd control. Ship-mounted phasers can damage shields or other systems or even cut a vessel's hull.

Phasers are based on the Rapid Nadion Effect, whereby energy is passed through a special phaser crystal resulting in a discharge of short-lived nadion particles (often the detection of nadion discharges is a key sign that a battle has recently taken place).

Posted by: Ghost of a flea [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 03:23 PM

In property law, the easement is characterized by the subservient tenement and the dominant one, the owner of the latter being the one able to walk on the land the former at their own will. Your superior knowledge again bests me.

Posted by: Alan McLeod [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 03:32 PM

You're so cool brewster.

Flea, I am impressed.

Posted by: Gorthos [TypeKey Profile Page] at November 3, 2006 08:25 PM